With WTI climbing past $40/bbl, many North American exploration and production companies (E&Ps) have been able to keep their heads above water as the COVID-19 pandemic added severe financial strain on an industry already reeling under billions of dollars of debt. However, unless prices strengthen further, about 150 more E&Ps will need to seek Chapter 11 protection through 2022, Rystad Energy analysis shows.
So far this year, 32 E&Ps have filed for Chapter 11, recording a cumulative debt of about $40 billion, according to Haynes and Boone LLP. On the oilfield services (OFS) front, 25 companies have filed for Chapter 11. If WTI remains at $40, Rystad Energy estimates 29 more E&P Chapter 11 filings this year, adding another $26 billion of debt at risk.
In a scenario with WTI continuing to hover around $40 over the next 2 years, Rystad Energy expects another 68 Chapter 11 filings from E&Ps in 2021, and 57 more in 2022, adding $58 billion and $44 billion, respectively, of more debt at risk. That would bring the total amount of E&P debt at risk from now until the end of 2022 to $128 billion.
If WTI price levels remain largely unchanged and the Chapter 11 forecasts materialize, this would bring the total number of North American E&P filings for 2020-2022 to nearly 190, compared to 207 during the 5-year period of 2015-2019. It would also bring total Chapter 11 North American E&P debt for 2020-2022 to about $168 billion, 36% higher than the $122 billion recorded in 2015-2019.
The number of filings so far is lower than what was recorded in the previous downturn, particularly in 2016, but total debt for the filings in the first 7 months of the year, for both E&Ps and OFS companies, is already at $70 billion—the same level as full-year 2016.
Looking at the average debt per company, 2020 seems to be an outlier, at $1.2 billion. The number is 160% higher than the average debt of $460 million in the 2015-2019 period and twice as much as the 2017 level, which was the second highest in terms of average debt in a year.
Both E&P and OFS Chapter 11 cases exhibit the same dynamic this year—with the average debt for an E&P at $1.25 billion and for an OFS company at $1.19 billion. The OFS sector usually has lower debt than E&Ps, as the former in the US is punctuated with small suppliers and service providers, whereas the capital structure of smaller E&Ps is typically fully family owned. The average debt for the OFS sector is higher this year because of several large bankruptcies.
Rystad Energy’s E&P Chapter 11 model is based on a cash flow analysis covering about 10,000 active North American oil and gas E&Ps. The model is designed to present a macro-level outlook rather than look at individual company insights, as the capital structure for a majority of small and private E&Ps is based on assumptions and matches the actual number of Chapter 11 cases.
“While an improvement in oil prices towards $40/bbl WTI saved a significant number of E&Ps and prevented early Chapter 11 filings in June-July, the current price environment is in no way sufficient for a large number of E&Ps in the medium-term. As hedging programs set at WTI $50+/bbl expire in the second half of this year, we anticipate greater financial pressure on the industry unless WTI prices recover further,” said Artem Abramov, Rystad Energy’s head of shale research.
