API: USGS did better job testing Pavillion water than EPA

Analysis of US Geological Survey testing of water samples taken from one of two US Environmental Protection Agency monitoring wells at Pavillion, Wyo., raises questions about the how EPA constructed monitoring wells and tested water samples, an American Petroleum Institute spokesman said.

Some Pavillion residents complained about drinking water, suggesting natural gas drilling and hydraulic fracturing contaminated certain water wells. In December 2011, EPA said it was “likely” that fracing contributed to water contamination based upon results from EPA’s two deep monitoring wells.

EPA released its conclusion in a draft report that identified levels of methane, ethane, diesel compounds, and phenol. Later, EPA retested the water in the Pavillion area.

Erik Milito, API director of upstream, told reporters in an Oct. 18 conference call that it appears EPA failed to follow sound scientific practices at Pavillion. Consequently, the idea of flawed research raises concerns about EPA’s pending national study on fracing and drinking water sources, he said.

“Unscientific testing could produce flawed results that could result in major adverse impacts on shale energy development and the vast potential it has to contribute to US jobs, US economic recovery, and US energy security,” Milito said.

USGS results were inconsistent with EPA’s results, he said. Given questions about EPA’s research, USGS collected its own scientific findings as part of a collaboration among the state of Wyoming, USGS, EPA, and the Wyoming Tribes. USGS did not analyze its findings (OGJ Online, Sept. 27, 2012).

Encana Oil & Gas (USA) owns wells in the area and questions the source of some chemicals found in the EPA water well samples (OGJ Online, Jan. 2, 2012).

The Calgary oil company argues contaminants found in Pavillion water wells are naturally occurring, and the two test wells that the EPA drilled in 2010 were improperly constructed.

API questions EPA

Milito said API believes USGS did a better job than EPA in analyzing the Pavillion water samples. For instance, USGS did not test samples from one of the two EPA water monitoring wells “because that well was unable to provide representative samples due to its low-flow characteristics.”

USGS tests did not contain several key compounds previously identified by EPA, he said. Those compounds included glycols and 2-butoxyethanol. Other materials previously found by the EPA were found at significantly lower concentrations by the USGS.

“In addition, while EPA has yet to acknowledge this, hydrocarbons are naturally occurring and have historically been detected in groundwater in the Pavillion area,” Milito said. “It is not unexpected to find hydrocarbons in groundwater in a hydrocarbon-bearing formation.”

He called the Pavillion analysis “critically important” because EPA needs to “start from scratch” in its procedures to drill water monitoring wells, collect, and analyze samples.

API believes EPA’s flaws include improper water monitoring well construction and development, possible cross-contamination of groundwater during EPA’s monitoring well drilling, development, and sampling, and misrepresentation of monitoring well depths vs. area drinking water well depths.

“If EPA thinks its investigation at Pavillion has produced scientifically useful information, then it may proceed in the same inexpert way at other testing sites,” Milito said, urging the federal government to avoid “regulatory obstacles based on flawed research.”

Others support EPA

The Sierra Club, Earthworks, and the Natural Resources Defense Council worked with independent hydrologist Tom Myers to analyze the USGS findings and compare those findings with the original EPA report. Myers concluded USGS results supported EPA’s initial findings.

In an Oct. 3 news release, the Sierra Club, Earthworks, and NRC said Myer's analysis of USGS findings supported the EPA’s draft report conclusion that gas drilling and fracing could have contaminated the Wind River aquifer near Pavillion.

Bruce Baizel, an attorney for Earthworks oil and gas accountability project, said, “It’s long past time for states and industry to stop denying oil and gas development’s environmental problems and start working on fixing them.”

Deb Nardone, Sierra Club Beyond Natural Gas campaign director, said EPA’s report “raises the alarm on the public general health threats posed by dirty and dangerous fracing and the need to rein in an oil and gas industry that remains unchecked and unaccountable for their toxic pollution.”

Contact Paula Dittrick at paulad@ogjonline.com.

Related Articles

BIS lists six considerations for condensate as a potential export

01/02/2015 The US Bureau of Industry and Security listed six considerations it will use to help determine whether US-produced crude oil condensate is a petrol...

Keystone XL looms large as 114th Congress prepares to meet

01/02/2015 The US Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee scheduled a hearing for Jan. 7 on legislation to approve the proposed Keystone XL crude oil pi...

American Eagle suspends oil drilling in Bakken for 2015

01/02/2015 American Eagle Energy Corp., Denver, has suspended its 2015 drilling budget and does not anticipate resuming drilling operations until crude oil pr...

MARKET WATCH: NYMEX crude oil futures end 2014 below $54/bbl

01/02/2015 The slump in oil prices worldwide continued on the last trading day of 2014 with US light, sweet crude closing at less than $54/bbl on the New York...

MARKET WATCH: NYMEX crude oil futures move up slightly awaiting inventory

12/31/2014 Crude oil prices on the New York market rose modestly on Dec. 30 awaiting the weekly US government report on crude oil and product supplies. Prices...

Williams postpones Geismar ethylene sales

12/31/2014 Williams Partners LP once again has postponed sales of ethylene production from its newly rebuilt Geismar, La., olefins plant amid ongoing efforts ...

Gazprom buys South Stream shares from partners

12/30/2014 OAO Gazprom has purchased shares in South Stream Transport BV from Italy’s Eni SPA 20%, Germany’s Wintershall AG 15%, and France’s EDF Energy 15%. ...

MARKET WATCH: NYMEX crude oil futures fall again, down 50% since June

12/30/2014 Crude oil prices on the New York market settled down by more than a $1/bbl on Dec. 29, reaching the lowest value since May 1, 2009, and analysts ex...

Trinidad and Tobago to develop ‘master plan’ for gas development

12/29/2014 Trinidad and Tobago’s government has hired UK-based consulting firm Poten & Partners to develop a natural gas master plan for the Caribbean twi...

White Papers

What is System Level Thermo-Fluid Analysis?

This paper will explain some of the fundamentals of System Level Thermo-Fluid Analysis and demonstrate...

Accurate Thermo-Fluid Simulation in Real Time Environments

The crux of any task undertaken in System Level Thermo-Fluid Analysis is striking a balance between ti...

6 ways for Energy, Chemical and Oil and Gas Companies to Avert the Impending Workforce Crisis

As many as half of the skilled workers in energy, chemical and oil & gas industries are quickly he...
Sponsored by

AVEVA NET Accesses and Manages the Digital Asset

Global demand for new process plants, power plants and infrastructure is increasing steadily with the ...
Sponsored by

AVEVA’s Approach for the Digital Asset

To meet the requirements for leaner project execution and more efficient operations while transferring...
Sponsored by

Diversification - the technology aspects

In tough times, businesses seek to diversify into adjacent markets or to apply their skills and resour...
Sponsored by

Engineering & Design for Lean Construction

Modern marketing rhetoric claims that, in order to cut out expensive costs and reduce risks during the...
Sponsored by

Object Lessons - Why control of engineering design at the object level is essential for efficient project execution

Whatever the task, there is usually only one way to do it right and many more to do it wrong. In the c...
Sponsored by

Available Webcasts



The Future of US Refining

When Fri, Feb 6, 2015

Oil & Gas Journal’s Feb. 6, 2015, webcast will focus on the future of US refining as various forces this year conspire to pull the industry in different directions. Lower oil prices generally reduce feedstock costs, but they have also lowered refiners’ returns, as 2015 begins with refined products priced at lows not seen in years. If lower per-barrel crude prices dampen production of lighter crudes among shale plays, what will happen to refiners’ plans to export more barrels of lighter crudes? And as always, refiners will be affected by government regulations, particularly those that suppress demand, increase costs, or limit access to markets or supply.

register:WEBCAST


Oil & Gas Journal’s Forecast & Review/Worldwide Pipeline Construction 2015

When Fri, Jan 30, 2015

The  Forecast & Review/Worldwide Pipeline Construction 2015 Webcast will address Oil & Gas Journal’s outlooks for the oil market and pipeline construction in a year of turbulence. Based on two annual special reports, the webcast will be presented by OGJ Editor Bob Tippee and OGJ Managing Editor-Technology Chris Smith.
The Forecast & Review portion of the webcast will identify forces underlying the collapse in crude oil prices and assess prospects for changes essential to recovery—all in the context of geopolitical pressures buffeting the market.

register:WEBCAST



On Demand

Optimizing your asset management practices to mitigate the effects of a down market

Thu, Dec 11, 2014

The oil and gas market is in constant flux, and as the price of BOE (Barrel of Oil Equivalent) goes down it is increasingly important to optimize your asset management strategy to stay afloat.  Attend this webinar to learn how developing a solid asset management plan can help your company mitigate costs in any market.

register:WEBCAST


Parylene Conformal Coatings for the Oil & Gas Industry

Thu, Nov 20, 2014

In this concise 30-minute webinar, participants have an opportunity to learn more about how Parylene coatings are applied, their features, and the value they add to devices and components.

register:WEBCAST


Careers at TOTAL

Careers at TOTAL - Videos

More than 600 job openings are now online, watch videos and learn more!

 

Click Here to Watch

Other Oil & Gas Industry Jobs

Search More Job Listings >>
Stay Connected