Why scorn report about shrinking mess in the gulf?

Bob Tippee
Editor

The Apr. 20 blowout of the Macondo wildcat off Louisiana, with its 11 deaths and consequent oiling of the Gulf of Mexico, wasn’t bad enough to suit some people.

Federal agencies reported early in August that an impressive amount of the oil released into the gulf had dispersed or evaporated. Environmentalists and their friends in government deemed that news too good.

“Bull,” declared a blogger for the Natural Resources Defense Council.

Rep. Ed Markey (D-Mass.), chairman of the energy and environment subcommittee of the House Commerce on Energy and Commerce, said the administration shouldn’t have released the report. According to the Politico web site, he complained it “basically sent the signal in regard to how much of the problem remains.”

Wasn’t that the point?

The report represented fate of the oil as shares of the 4.9 million bbl the government estimates to have been released. Its findings: direct recovery from the wellhead 17%, burned 5%, skimmed 3%, chemically dispersed 8%, naturally dispersed 16%, evaporated or dissolved 25%, and residual 26%.

Natural degradation continues for residual and dispersed oil.

Clearly, the spill isn’t the mess it was just a few weeks ago and was expected indefinitely to remain.

Oil has slimed shoreline—but not as much as was earlier feared. Little oil remains afloat. Scientific groups report “plumes” of oil below ocean surface, but concentrations are so low the oil can’t be seen.

Environmental damage has occurred, of course. There will be more. But maybe real damage won’t be as ugly as the initial mess. This is good news.

What the government report shows is that nature has strong mechanisms of adjustment. Other spills have demonstrated how well those mechanisms work.

There can be only one reason to scorn the report’s conclusions—that they drain extremist political agendas of the manufactured desperation on which they feed. 

For anyone with a heatlhy sense of hope toward the end of a long, tense summer, they offer a welcome reason to cheer.

(Online Aug. 20, 2010; author’s e-mail: bobt@ogjonline.com)

Related Articles

Industry a target as inversions revive talk of tax reform

08/29/2014

New talk in the US about tax reform should make oil and gas companies nervous.

Can anyone name top agency in count of restrictive regs?

08/22/2014

The leader in a new measure of regulatory activism is—can anyone guess?

Study links states’ economic growth to energy regulation

08/14/2014 Judged strictly by economic efficiency, energy regulation at the state level works best in the US South and interior and worst on the West Coast an...

Russia hit by court claims over Yukos it likely will defy

08/08/2014 Battered lately in the worldwide court of public opinion over its strong-arming of Ukraine, Russia last month sustained two blows in international ...

Careers at TOTAL

Careers at TOTAL - Videos

More than 600 job openings are now online, watch videos and learn more!

 

Click Here to Watch

Other Oil & Gas Industry Jobs

Search More Job Listings >>
Stay Connected