Lawsuits point to climate change litigation threat

 

Editor's note: This story was updated on Oct. 23, adding additional quotes.

Paula Dittrick
OGJ Senior Staff Writer

HOUSTON, Oct. 22 -- A climate change litigation threat appears to be looming for the oil and gas industry in the wake of a US Supreme Court decision allowing the regulation of greenhouse gases as air pollutants.

Federal courts recently issued conflicting decisions in climate change litigation. One case involved Murphy Oil USA, and another case involved ExxonMobil Corp. and others. Power companies face the same issues.

The recent litigation all stems from an Apr. 2, 2007, decision in which the Supreme Court ruled that the Environmental Protection Agency has authority under the Clean Air Act to regulate greenhouse gases. That ruling came in a lawsuit filed by Massachusetts and several other states, US cities, and environmental groups.

On Sept. 21, the US Circuit Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit in New York City allowed a coalition of eight states, New York City, and environmental groups to sue coal-burning utilities over climate change. That ruling later was cited in the Murphy Oil ruling.

Anthony Cavender of the Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP law firm in Houston said, “Given that the Obama administration has already advocated for tighter regulations related to the environment as a whole, and in particular for tougher policies governing carbon emissions, many plaintiffs may now feel that the time is right to file such suits.”

Murphy Oil suit
On Oct. 16, a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit in New Orleans said residents and land owners along the Gulf Coast in Mississippi could seek relief for Hurricane Katrina damages presumed to be related to global warming.

The appeals court ruling in the case of Ned Comer vs. Murphy Oil USA reversed a decision from the US District court for the Southern District of Mississippi, which had dismissed the case.

The appeals court ruled that Comer could assert claims that Murphy Oil operations caused greenhouse gas emissions and contributed to global warming and a rise in sea levels that consequently strengthened Hurricane Katrina.

Comer and others, seeking compensatory and punitive damages, argued they had the legal standing to litigate these claims based on the 2007 Supreme Court decision.

Judge James Dennis in New Orleans wrote that the court arrived at its decision independently but that the “Second Circuit’s reasoning [in Connecticut vs. AEP] is fully consistent with ours, particularly in its careful analysis of whether the case requires the court to address any specific issue that is constitutionally committed to another branch of government.”

ExxonMobil suit
Separately, the US District Court for the Northern District of California in late September dismissed a climate change lawsuit that Inupiat Eskimos living in Kivalina, Alas., near the Arctic Circle filed against ExxonMobil.

The plaintiffs alleged that 24 oil, energy, and utility companies emitted greenhouse gases that contribute to global warming and consequently diminish sea ice that protects their village from winter storms and erosion.

The California court dismissed the lawsuit for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and because the Inupiat Eskimos could not prove the companies caused any injury. An attorney for the town of Kivalina has said he plans to appeal.

Sheila Harvey, a partner with Pillsbury’s climate change and sustainability team in Washington, DC, said that while each case must be individually evaluated on the merits of evidence, she noted that “The decision in Kivalina is more in keeping with how courts have traditionally ruled—often dismissing these types of cases as ‘nuisance suits’ filed by plaintiffs for no other purpose than to cause headaches for companies they politically or personally disagree with.”

Suggestions for industry
John R. Eldridge, an attorney with Haynes and Boone LLP in Houston, notes the lesson for the oil and gas industry is that it cannot expect immediate dismissal of claims associated with damages allegedly caused by GHG emissions.

“This is not saying that a state or tribe or city or individual pursuing one of these clams to abate the nuisance will get an order enjoining an oil company or refinery from emitting carbon dioxide,” Eldridge said. “We still don’t know how these cases will ultimately turn out.”

Meanwhile, he advises oil companies to be prepared in case they get targeted in a tort claim involving climate change.

“Companies need to figure out what their position should be about legislation based on the fact that they may be defending these kinds of cases if there is not a fix or a resolution by the US Supreme Court or by Congress,” Eldridge said.

“I think this is going to be a wake up call for the industry,” he said, referring specifically to the Kivalina case. “I think most people had some sense that these claims were so far out that they would be dismissed upfront as political or for lack of standing.”

Peter S. Glaser, a partner with Troutman Sanders LLP in Washington, said, “We are having a cataclysm going on in federal and state tort law as it apples to climate change. This is really extraordinary, and I can’t overstate to you the importance of this.”

Speaking during a webcast briefing arranged by the Western Business Roundtable, Glaser said the implication stemming from the recent court decisions is that any GHG emitter, including fossil fuel producers, can be sued.

“The amount of emissions didn’t seem to matter…basically any emitter of greenhouse gases and any producer of fossil fuels…can also be sued,” Glaser said.

For instance, plaintiffs can sue an oil company and seek an injunction where, if successful, a judge could say stop emitting, use some other type of fuel, or reduce emissions, he said.

“But even worse, you can be sued in damages,” Glaser said. “The really worrisome part of the case in Mississippi was that the plaintiffs were property owners in the Hurricane Katrina area represented by old-time, well-known plaintiff trial lawyers. These people don’t care about global warming, and they don’t care about proper public policy. They want money…. It’s even more worrisome because in effect we will have global warming policy now because that is what is really at stake here,” if judges and juries can tell oil companies to change their behavior.

Contact Paula Dittrick at paulad@ogjonline.com.

Related Articles

PT Pertamina to acquire Malaysian assets for $2 billion

09/30/2014 PT Pertamina Malaysia Eksplorasi Produksi has agreed to acquire 30% of the Malaysian oil and gas assets belonging to Murphy Sabah Oil Co. Ltd. and ...

Murphy Oil acquires ethanol plant

10/02/2009

A subsidiary of Murphy Oil Corp. has purchased a corn-based ethanol plant in Hankinson, ND, for $92 million.

NPC to study future transport fuels, N. American oil and gas

09/18/2009 US Energy Secretary Steven Chu would like the National Petroleum Council to conduct studies on future transportation fuels and on prudent developme...

PTT unveils 5-year, $6 billion investment plan

12/29/2008 Thailand's PTT PCL has approved a 5-year investment budget of $6.6 billion, with more than half of the funding earmarked for the natural gas industry.

Murphy, PTTEP win Block WA-423-P off Australia

11/23/2008 In the 2008 Australian bidding round, the partnership of Murphy Oil and Thailand's PTTEP won an offshore Australian block said to possess high hydr...

Murphy-led group granted Block Semai II off Indonesia

11/13/2008 A consortium comprising Murphy Oil Corp. (operator), Thailand's PTT Exploration & Production PLC (PTTEP), and Inpex Corp. of Japan was awarded offs...

Murphy Oil makes executive changes

08/07/2008 Murphy Oil Corp. announced that Claiborne P. Deming, president and chief executive officer of the company since 1994, will retire effective Dec. 31.

MARKET WATCH: Heat drives up energy prices

06/03/2008 Energy prices continued to climb June 2 as warm weather increased demand for both natural gas and heating oil.

PA Resources buys 35% Azurite Marine field stake

04/22/2008 PA Resources AB has acquired a 35% interest in exploration license Mer Profond Sud and Azurite Marine field in Congo (Brazzaville) from Murphy West...
White Papers

Pipeline Integrity: Best Practices to Prevent, Detect, and Mitigate Commodity Releases

Commodity releases can have catastrophic consequences, so ensuring pipeline integrity is crucial for p...
Sponsored by

AVEVA’s Digital Asset Approach - Defining a new era of collaboration in capital projects and asset operations

There is constant, intensive change in the capital projects and asset life cycle management. New chall...
Sponsored by

Transforming the Oil and Gas Industry with EPPM

With budgets in the billions, timelines spanning years, and life cycles extending over decades, oil an...
Sponsored by

Asset Decommissioning in Oil & Gas: Transforming Business

Asset intensive organizations like Oil and Gas have their own industry specific challenges when it com...
Sponsored by

Squeezing the Green: How to Cut Petroleum Downstream Costs and Optimize Processing Efficiencies with Enterprise Project Portfolio Management Solutions

As the downstream petroleum industry grapples with change in every sector and at every level, includin...
Sponsored by

7 Steps to Improve Oil & Gas Asset Decommissioning

Global competition and volatile markets are creating a challenging business climate for project based ...
Sponsored by

The impact of aging infrastructure in process manufacturing industries

Process manufacturing companies in the oil and gas, utilities, chemicals and natural resource industri...
Sponsored by

What is System Level Thermo-Fluid Analysis?

This paper will explain some of the fundamentals of System Level Thermo-Fluid Analysis and demonstrate...
Available Webcasts


The Alternative Fuel Movement: Four Need-to-Know Excise Tax Complexities

When Thu, Jun 4, 2015

Discussion on how to approach, and ultimately embrace, the alternative fuel market by pulling back the veil on excise tax complexities. Taxes may be an aggravating part of daily operations, but their accuracy is crucial in your path towards business success.

register:WEBCAST



On Demand

Prevention, Detection and Mitigation of pipeline leaks in the modern world

Thu, Apr 30, 2015

Preventing, detecting and mitigating leaks or commodity releases from pipelines are a top priority for all pipeline companies. This presentation will look at various aspects related to preventing, detecting and mitigating pipeline commodity releases from a generic and conceptual point of view, while at the same time look at the variety of offerings available from Schneider Electric to meet some of the requirements associated with pipeline integrity management. 

register:WEBCAST


Global LNG: Adjusting to New Realities

Fri, Mar 20, 2015

Oil & Gas Journal’s March 20, 2015, webcast will look at how global LNG trade will be affected over the next 12-24 months by falling crude oil prices and changing patterns and pressures of demand. Will US LNG production play a role in balancing markets? Or will it add to a growing global oversupply of LNG for markets remote from easier natural gas supply? Will new buyers with marginal credit, smaller requirements, or great need for flexibility begin to look attractive to suppliers? How will high-cost, mega-projects in Australia respond to new construction cost trends?

register:WEBCAST


US Midstream at a Crossroads

Fri, Mar 6, 2015

Oil & Gas Journal’s Mar. 6, 2015, webcast will focus on US midstream companies at an inflection point in their development in response to more than 6 years shale oil and gas production growth. Major infrastructure—gas plants, gathering systems, and takeaway pipelines—have been built. Major fractionation hubs have expanded. Given the radically changed pricing environment since mid-2014, where do processors go from here? What is the fate of large projects caught in mid-development? How to producers and processors cooperate to ensure a sustainable and profitable future? This event will serve to set the discussion table for the annual GPA Convention in San Antonio, Apr. 13-16, 2015.

This event is sponsored by Leidos Engineering.

register:WEBCAST


Emerson Micro Motion Videos

Careers at TOTAL

Careers at TOTAL - Videos

More than 600 job openings are now online, watch videos and learn more!

 

Click Here to Watch

Other Oil & Gas Industry Jobs

Search More Job Listings >>
Stay Connected