Federal probe cites budget cuts for BP plant blast

Nick Snow
Washington Correspondent

WASHINGTON, DC, Oct. 31 -- Years of budget reductions contributed to conditions leading up to the Mar. 23, 2005, explosion at BP America Inc.'s 460,000-b/d Texas City, Tex., refinery, which killed 15 workers and injured 180 others, the US Chemical Safety Board said Oct. 30.

Investigators also found that BP was aware of problems at the facility but implemented reforms aimed at improving compliance with procedures and reducing occupational injuries while ignoring potentially catastrophic safety risks, the CSB said as it released preliminary findings of its investigation.

It was the first significant update of the board's investigation since Oct. 27, 2005, when the first set of findings was released at a public meeting of Texas City residents and refinery employees. The CSB scheduled an additional news conference for Oct. 31 in Houston but said it probably would not issue a final report before March 2007 because the investigation is so complex.

"Unsafe and antiquated equipment designs were left in place, and unacceptable deficiencies in preventive maintenance were tolerated," CSB Chairman Carolyn W. Merritt said.

Previously, the board indicated that the equipment involved in the explosion of an isomerization unit was of an obsolete design that had been phased out at most other refineries and that supervisors at the Texas City plant knew key instruments did not work or were unreliable (OGJ, Nov. 21, 2005, p. 32).

BP spokesman Ronnie Chappell said the company agrees with the CSB's conclusions that the accident could have been prevented. He said the findings of its own investigation are generally consistent with those of the CSB's inquiry (OGJ, Jan. 23, 2006, p. 51).

"We do not understand the basis for some of the comments made by the CSB," he said by e-mail on Oct. 31. "We have and will continue to discuss our concerns with the board. We are not going to comment publicly on the statement of the CSB until the board issues a final written report that we hope will explain in more detail the basis for some of their preliminary findings."

Budget cuts
Stringent budget cuts across BP PLC's worldwide operations caused safety at the Texas City refinery to deteriorate, Merritt said. "BP implemented a 25% cut on fixed costs from 1998 to 2000 that adversely impacted maintenance expenditures and infrastructure at the refinery," she said.

Maintenance spending had fallen through the 1990s when Amoco Corp. owned the refinery, according to Merritt. Additional cuts were imposed after BP acquired Amoco, she said.

"Every successful corporation must contain its costs. But at an aging facility like Texas City, it is not responsible to cut budgets related to safety and maintenance without thoroughly examining the impact on the risk of a catastrophic accident," she maintained.

CSB found that, by 2002, an internal BP report had identified cost reductions as a contributor to eroding infrastructure at the refinery that would take a large investment to correct.

These findings were corroborated in a 2005 survey of the refinery's safety culture known as the Telos study just prior to the accident, the federal investigators found. They said the survey's interview with the refinery's manager identified a history of reduced budgets and a culture of "things not getting fixed."

Merritt said: "The refinery manager was not alone in this candid assessment. Large majorities of the survey respondents reported significant maintenance backlogs that were harming safety. Disturbingly, most employees agreed that 'production and budget compliance gets recognized before anything else at Texas City.'"

Economic pressures were apparent in many decisions that contributed to the explosion, the CSB said. In 2002, the refinery undertook an environmental initiative known as Clean Streams, which led to plans to eliminate the isomerization unit blowdown drum involved in the March 2005 explosion.

"To economize, a decision was made not to replace the blowdown drum with a flare system," said Don Holmstrom, CSB lead investigator. "The refinery did not conduct federally required safety reviews that likely would have taken into account BP's own existing policy recommending the elimination of blowdown drums."

A required study of the isomerization unit's relief valve system was never completed, although the need was first identified in 1993, the CSB added.

It also found that the refinery's central training staff was reduced from 30 employees in 1997 to 8 in 2004, and the training department budget was cut in half from 1998 to 2004. Trainers also were given other duties so that some spent little time actually training other employees, it said. The isomerization trainer spent only 5% of his time on training, the CSB said.

The control board operations staff also was shrunk, and workloads were increased, the investigators found. Four open-process safety coordinator positions for the isomerization and other area units were not filled prior to the explosion, the CSB said. Its earlier preliminary findings cited operator fatigue and a lack of effective training and supervision.

Culture problems
Chappell said BP's own investigation, which acknowledges the company was aware of infrastructure and safety culture problems at the refinery before the explosion and fire, found that the problems were "many years in the making."

It also notes that BP was working to address the problems before the accident by spending more money on operations, maintenance, and plant integrity and through efforts to reduce the number of workplace accidents and injuries, Chappell said.

The company held discussions of previous fatal accidents at the refinery and put in place a new "control of work" audit team to ensure compliance with safety rules during maintenance and other activities at the plant, he added.

Chappell said that while BP achieved a 70% reduction in workplace injury rates at Texas City, the CSB's investigators "determined these efforts were not sufficient because they focused on personal safety rather than process safety." He said the lower workplace injury rates led the company "to believe that conditions at the refinery were improving."

He also said BP's own investigation did not identify previous budget decisions or lack of expenditures as a critical factor or immediate cause of the accident.

"Indeed, the [BP] report points out that maintenance and turnaround spending in the years prior to the incident had increased as Texas City staff addressed the safety and plant integrity issues of greatest concern. Maintenance spending had increased 40% over the previous 5 years and was higher than the industry average per barrel of throughput," Chappell said.

He said BP is eliminating the use of blowdown stacks in heavier-than-air light hydrocarbon service and will eliminate their use at Texas City when it recommissions the refinery and at other BP facilities in the US by 2008.

The company also has adopted a new engineering technical practice governing the use of temporary buildings in refineries and other plants and has moved more than 200 such buildings out of the Texas City refinery or emptied and locked them, he said.

"At Texas City, the new management team has simplified the organization, clarified accountabilities, and removed hundreds of workers from process areas," Chappell said. "BP will spend more than $1 billion at Texas City over the next 5 years to refurbish and rebuild key gasoline production units, install modern process control systems, transition to a more powerful maintenance management system, improve worker training and implement the other recommendations contained in our final report."

Merritt also praised BP's actions following the accident. The company "has expressed a strong desire to improve its safety performance globally, has made organizational changes to better identify and communicate risks, and has done extensive positive outreach to the rest of the industrial community," she said.

She noted that BP also followed the CSB's recommendation that it voluntarily fund and support the work of an independent panel examining the company's safety culture. The panel, chaired by former US Sec. of State James A. Baker III, is expected to report its findings on the safety of BP's five North American refineries in late November.

Contact Nick Snow at nsnow@cox.net.

Related Articles

California Bay Area advances plan for enhanced refinery regulations

12/19/2014 California’s Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD), the public agency responsible for regulating stationary sources of air pollution in...

ExxonMobil lets contract for Antwerp refinery

12/17/2014 ExxonMobil Petroleum & Chemical BVBA has let an engineering, procurement, and construction contract to Fluor Corp. for a delayed coker to be in...

BPC report examines 40 possible options to reform RFS

12/16/2014 The Bipartisan Policy Center issued a report outlining 40 possible options for reforming the federal Renewable Fuels Standard in an effort to move ...

Turkish refinery secures Canadian financing

12/16/2014 Export Development Canada (EDC) said it is participating as lead arranger in the $3.3 billion debt-financing consortium supporting STAR Rafineri AS...

Angola’s Sonangol secures $2 billion loan for refinery, other projects

12/15/2014 China Development Bank (CDB) has extended a $2 billion line of credit to state-owned Sonangol EP to support expansion projects in Angola’s oil and ...

Pertamina plans $25 billion revamp of Indonesian refineries

12/15/2014 PT Pertamina (Persoro) has entered agreements with Saudi Aramco, JX Nippon Oil & Energy Corp., and China Petroleum & Chemical Corp. (Sinope...

PBF Energy, PBF Logistics make management changes

12/12/2014 Matthew Lucey, currently executive vice-president of PBF Energy Inc., will succeed Michael Gayda as the company’s president. Todd O’Malley, current...

Repairs under way at ORPIC’s Muscat refinery

12/11/2014 Oman Oil Refineries & Petroleum Industries Co. (ORPIC) said it plans to resume operations at its 106,000-b/d Mina Al Fahal refinery near Muscat...

Phillips 66 advances plans for splitter at Sweeny refinery

12/11/2014 Phillips 66 has filed an application with state regulators for a permit to build a condensate splitter at its 247,000-b/d Sweeny refinery in Old Oc...

White Papers

AVEVA NET Accesses and Manages the Digital Asset

Global demand for new process plants, power plants and infrastructure is increasing steadily with the ...
Sponsored by

AVEVA’s Approach for the Digital Asset

To meet the requirements for leaner project execution and more efficient operations while transferring...
Sponsored by

Diversification - the technology aspects

In tough times, businesses seek to diversify into adjacent markets or to apply their skills and resour...
Sponsored by

Engineering & Design for Lean Construction

Modern marketing rhetoric claims that, in order to cut out expensive costs and reduce risks during the...
Sponsored by

Object Lessons - Why control of engineering design at the object level is essential for efficient project execution

Whatever the task, there is usually only one way to do it right and many more to do it wrong. In the c...
Sponsored by

Plant Design for Lean Construction - at your fingertips

One area which can provide improvements to the adoption of Lean principles is the application of mobil...
Sponsored by

How to Keep Your Mud System Vibrator Hose from Getting Hammered to Death

To prevent the vibrating hoses on your oilfield mud circulation systems from failing, you must examine...
Sponsored by

Duty of Care

Good corporate social responsibility means implementing effective workplace health and safety measures...
Sponsored by

Available Webcasts

On Demand

Optimizing your asset management practices to mitigate the effects of a down market

Thu, Dec 11, 2014

The oil and gas market is in constant flux, and as the price of BOE (Barrel of Oil Equivalent) goes down it is increasingly important to optimize your asset management strategy to stay afloat.  Attend this webinar to learn how developing a solid asset management plan can help your company mitigate costs in any market.


Parylene Conformal Coatings for the Oil & Gas Industry

Thu, Nov 20, 2014

In this concise 30-minute webinar, participants have an opportunity to learn more about how Parylene coatings are applied, their features, and the value they add to devices and components.


Utilizing Predictive Analytics to Optimize Productivity in Oil & Gas Operations

Tue, Nov 18, 2014

Join IBM on Tuesday, November 18 @ 1pm CST to explore how Predictive Analytics can help your organization maximize productivity, operational performance & associated processes to drive enterprise wide productivity and profitability.



Fri, Nov 14, 2014

US LNG Exports, the third in a trilogy of webcasts focusing on the broad topic of US Hydrocarbon Exports.

A discussion of the problems and potential for the export of US-produced liquefied natural gas.

These and other topics will be discussed, with the latest thoughts on U.S. LNG export policy.


Careers at TOTAL

Careers at TOTAL - Videos

More than 600 job openings are now online, watch videos and learn more!


Click Here to Watch

Other Oil & Gas Industry Jobs

Search More Job Listings >>
Stay Connected