PIRINC: Refiner consolidation not a cause of gasoline price spikes

Sam Fletcher
OGJ Senior Writer

HOUSTON, May 6 -- Competition among US refiners is still strong, said the Petroleum Industry Research Foundation Inc. (PIRINC), prior to hearings Tuesday by a Senate subcommittee investigating whether industry mergers have pushed up US gasoline prices at the pump.

Click here to enlarge image

"It would be wrong to conclude that the US refining industry has become less competitive since 1996. National concentration levels in refining remain relatively low in comparison with other US industries, and in any event, most economists—and antitrust regulators and the courts—long ago abandoned the dogma that increased concentration in itself is anticompetitive," said the PIRINC report authors Larry Goldstein, Ron Gold, John Lichtblau, and Jim Arrowsmith.

During the last few years, PIRINC acknowledged, "there has been significant turnover among the largest refiners, encouraged by Federal Trade Commission actions." But at the same time, it noted, "The FTC has acted to curb what was believed were potential threats to competition, requiring divestitures in certain cases where it believed necessary while not objecting to consolidations where it saw no potential anticompetitive effects."

Sen. Carl Levin (D-Mich), chairman of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, released his own report Monday alleging that consolidation of the refining industry forced gasoline prices up by reducing supply. Subcommittee staff members criticized the legal practice of "zone pricing" to charge different prices for gasoline to different station operators, some of which are in nearby geographic areas, in order to "confine price competition to the smallest area possible and to maximize their prices and revenues at each retail outlet."

The report said oil companies sought to circumvent antitrust laws by shrinking the size of the zone in some cases to just one retail outlet.

Levin began hearings Tuesday on his subcommittee's 10-month investigation of gasoline prices. Officials from industry, academia and state government were scheduled to testify Tuesday and Thursday (OGJ Online, Apr. 30, 2002). Industry witnesses expected to testify include executives from BP America Inc., ExxonMobil Corp., Marathon Ashland Petroleum LLC, ChevronTexaco Corp., and Shell Oil Co.

Refiner mix changed

A series of major mergers in the past 6 years created some "supermajors," such as ExxonMobil and ChevronTexaco but also transformed some smaller companies, including some independents, into major players among refiners. "This process has boosted concentration levels in the US refining sector and at the same time changed the mix of players," said PIRINC researchers.

As a result, the five largest US refiners accounted for 44% of total US crude refining capacity (crude distillation) at the start of this year, up significantly from 32% at the beginning of 1996. But there also was "a noticeable turnover" among the leading refiners "with Phillips (Petroleum Co., Bartlesville, Okla.,) and Valero (Energy Corp., San Antonio) climbing up into the national top five and Shell dropping out," said PIRINC.

The five largest US refiners are ExxonMobil, with 12% of all US refining capacity; Phillips, 10%; BP, 9%; Valero, 7%; and ChevronTexaco, 6%.

Moreover, PIRINC said, "The FTC focuses on conditions in specific geographic markets, not national concentration statistics. Any assessment of the impact of recent mergers on competition must also consider regional impacts rather than simply changes in the national aggregates."

Looking at which refiners control what capacity in the five US Petroleum Administration for Defense Districts (PADD), PIRINC concluded, "There is an important distinction between the largest refiners on a regional basis and the largest refiners nationally." The biggest refiners nationally are not always the biggest players, or even present, in each PADD.

Due to staff and time constraints, the investigation launched by Levin's staff in June 2001, following dramatic gasoline price spikes in the Midwest, focused on three regions: the West Coast, California in particular; the Midwest, primarily Michigan, Ohio, and Illinois; and the East Coast, with a special emphasis on Maine and the Washington, DC, area.

However, PIRINC analysts said a close look at the refining capacity in those areas doesn't support the subcommittee staff's allegations.

In PADD 1, which extends the length of the US East Coast, they said, "The national top five currently have only a 27% share of refining capacity within the region, up somewhat from 19% in 1996 and well below the current 90% share of the top five refiners operating within the region.

"Of the national top five, only Phillips and Valero have any refining capacity within the region. The largest refiner within PADD 1 is Sunoco (Inc., Philadelphia,) with a 32% share of local capacity as opposed to a 4% share of national capacity in 2002."

What's more, they said, "None of the mergers of recent years has involved an FTC-required divesture of PADD 1 refining assets, in part reflecting the relatively modest presence of the largest national refiners."

In PADD 2, which encompasses the upper Midwest US, the top five local refiners made "only a modest increase" to a 56% share from 48% in 1966. The share commanded by the five largest national refiners "is much lower, 33% in 2002, and only marginally higher than in 1996," said PIRINC. The largest refiner in that region is Marathon Ashland, with some 18% of PADD 2 refining capacity and a 5.5% share nationwide.

The region also is open to competition from outside sources. Refiners in PADD 3, which includes Gulf Coast states from Texas to Alabama, along with New Mexico and Arkansas, supply almost 20% of PADD 2's gasoline demand. "External supply potential is growing with the introduction of the Centennial Pipeline running from Beaumont, Tex., to Bourbon, Ill.," PIRINC reported.

PADD 5, which includes the US West Coast, Alaska, and Hawaii, "is different," said PIRINC.

"Here, not only is the share of the largest regional refiners high at nearly 70%, but the presence of the largest national refiners is high as well. Moreover, the particular CARB reformulated gasoline specifications have left this market less accessible to suppliers from outside the region," PIRINC reported. "This is the region where the FTC has been most active in requiring divestitures of refining assets."

Price Spikes

Gasoline price spikes experienced by US motorists in 2000 and again in the first half of 2001 were especially acute in California and the Chicago-Milwaukee area.

However, PIRINC analysts reported, "The spikes did not reflect any lack of competition among refiners. They have resulted from infrastructure bottlenecks, including tight refining capacity, as well as stringent, location-specific polices regulating product quality."

Those price run-ups eventually were eased "first by exceptionally high refinery runs and then by a weakening economy and seasonal demand declines."

PIRINC said, "At the beginning of this year, retail prices were down about 60¢/gal from their spring peak, far more than then 21¢/gal decline in crude prices for the same period. But structural problems remain and show signs of reemergence as strong economic recovery and rising demand, as well as rising crude prices, fuel upward movements in gasoline prices."

It concluded, "Some steps have been taken to ease local problems—or at least to avoid further aggravating them. But more is needed. Misplaced concerns over industry concentration must not divert policy-makers from a serious discussion of this issue."

Contact Sam Fletcher at samf@ogjonline.com

Related Articles

FourPoint Energy to acquire Anadarko basin assets from Chesapeake

07/02/2015 FourPoint Energy LLC, a privately owned Denver company, plans to acquire oil and gas assets from Chesapeake Energy Corp. subsidiaries Chesapeake Ex...

Puma Energy completes purchase of Murco’s UK refinery, terminals

07/02/2015 Singapore-based Puma Energy Group Pte. has completed its purchase of UK midstream and downstream assets from Murco Petroleum Ltd., a subsidiary of ...

BP to settle federal, state Deepwater Horizon claims for $18.7 billion

07/02/2015 BP Exploration & Production Inc. has agreed in principle to settle all federal and state claims arising from the 2010 Deepwater Horizon inciden...

MARKET WATCH: NYMEX oil prices plummet on crude inventory build, Iran deadline extension

07/02/2015 Oil prices plummeted more than $2/bbl July 1 to settle at a 2-month low on the New York market after a weekly government report showed the first ri...

Shell Midstream Partners takes interest in Poseidon oil pipeline

07/01/2015 Shell Midstream Partners LP has completed its acquisition of 36% equity interest in Poseidon Oil Pipeline Co. LLC from Equilon Enterprises LLC, a s...

SIBUR plans MTBE expansion at Togliattikauchuk

07/01/2015 Russian conglomerate OAO SIBUR Holding, Moscow, has started preparatory work for a project designed to expand production capacity for methyl tertia...

MARKET WATCH: Oil prices decline as US crude inventories post first gain in 9 weeks

07/01/2015 Oil prices on July 1 surrendered much of their gains from the day before after the release of a government report showing the first rise in US crud...

Tullow Oil provides production update on Jubilee, other fields

07/01/2015 Tullow Oil PLC reported that gross production for the Jubilee field offshore Ghana averaged 105,000 b/d in this year’s first half, up from 102,000 ...

OxyChem-Mexichem JV lets contract for ethylene storage

06/30/2015 Ingleside Ethylene LLC, a 50-50 joint venture of Occidental Chemical Corp. (OxyChem) and Mexichem SAB de CV (Mexichem), has let a contract to CB&am...
White Papers

UAS Integration for Infrastructure: More than Just Flying

Oil and gas companies recognize the benefits that the use of drones or unmanned aerial systems (UAS) c...

Solutions to Financial Distress Resulting from a Weak Oil and Gas Price Environment

The oil and gas industry is in the midst of a prolonged worldwide downturn in commodity prices. While ...
Sponsored by

2015 Global Engineering Information Management Solutions Competitive Strategy Innovation and Leadership Award

The Frost & Sullivan Best Practices Awards recognise companies in a variety of regional and global...
Sponsored by

Three Tips to Improve Safety in the Oil Field

Working oil fields will always be tough work with inherent risks. There’s no getting around that. Ther...
Sponsored by

Pipeline Integrity: Best Practices to Prevent, Detect, and Mitigate Commodity Releases

Commodity releases can have catastrophic consequences, so ensuring pipeline integrity is crucial for p...
Sponsored by

AVEVA’s Digital Asset Approach - Defining a new era of collaboration in capital projects and asset operations

There is constant, intensive change in the capital projects and asset life cycle management. New chall...
Sponsored by

Transforming the Oil and Gas Industry with EPPM

With budgets in the billions, timelines spanning years, and life cycles extending over decades, oil an...
Sponsored by

Asset Decommissioning in Oil & Gas: Transforming Business

Asset intensive organizations like Oil and Gas have their own industry specific challenges when it com...
Sponsored by
Available Webcasts


Operating a Sustainable Oil & Gas Supply Chain in North America

When Wed, Oct 7, 2015

Short lead times and unpredictable conditions in the Oil & Gas industry can create costly challenges in supply chains. By implementing a LEAN culture of continuous improvement you can eliminate waste, increase productivity and gain end-to-end visibility leading to a sustainable and well-oiled supply chain.

Please join us for this webcast sponsored by Ryder System, Inc.

register:WEBCAST


The Resilient Oilfield in the Internet of Things World

When Tue, Sep 22, 2015

As we hear about the hype surrounding the Internet of Things, the oil and gas industry is questioning what is different than what is already being done. What is new?  Using sensors and connecting devices is nothing new to our mode of business and in many ways the industry exemplifies many principles of an industrial internet of things. How does the Internet of Things impact the oil and gas industry?

Prolific instrumentation and automation digitized the industry and has changed the approach to business models calling for a systems led approach.  Resilient Systems have the ability to adapt to changing circumstances while maintaining their central purpose.  A resilient system, such as Maximo, allows an asset intensive organization to leverage connected devices by merging real-time asset information with other critical asset information and using that information to create a more agile organization.  

Join this webcast, sponsored by IBM, to learn how about Internet of Things capabilities and resilient systems are impacting the landscape of the oil and gas industry.

register:WEBCAST



On Demand

Taking the Headache out of Fuel License and Exemption Certificates: How to Ensure Compliance

Tue, Aug 25, 2015

This webinar, brought to you by Avalara, will detail the challenges of tax document management, as well as recommend solutions for fuel suppliers. You will learn:

-    Why it’s critical to track business partner licenses and exemption documents
-    The four key business challenges of ensuring tax compliance through document management
-    Best practice business processes to minimize exposure to tax errors

register:WEBCAST


Driving Growth and Efficiency with Deep Insights into Operational Data

Wed, Aug 19, 2015

Capitalizing on today’s momentum in Oil & Gas requires operational excellence based on a clear view of what your business data is telling you. Which is why nearly half* of oil and gas companies have deployed SAP HANA or have it on their roadmap.

Join SAP and Red Hat to learn more about using data to drive process improvements and identify new opportunities with the SAP HANA platform running on Red Hat Enterprise Linux. This webinar will also show how your choice of infrastructure impacts the performance of core business applications and your ability to achieve data-driven insights quickly and reliably.

*48% use SAP, http://go.sap.com/solution/industry/oil-gas.html

register:WEBCAST


Emerson Micro Motion Videos

Careers at TOTAL

Careers at TOTAL - Videos

More than 600 job openings are now online, watch videos and learn more!

 

Click Here to Watch

Other Oil & Gas Industry Jobs

Search More Job Listings >>
Stay Connected